SESSION 2 OF 5 · SESSION SUPPORT
The Solar System
What makes a planet a planet?
45 MINUTES
01
Open the plan
02
Open the slides
03
04 · FOR STUDENTS
COMING SOON
MAIN THEME
The planets formed from the tiny fraction of leftover material the Sun did not claim. Whether something qualifies as a planet depends not on size alone, but on where it orbits, whether it has been shaped into a sphere and whether it has cleared its path.
BY THE END OF THIS SESSION, LEARNERS SHOULD BE ABLE TO
Explain the process of planetary accretion, from dust grains through planetesimals to protoplanets.
Describe how the Moon formed from the debris of a massive collision between Earth and a Mars-sized object called Theia.
Explain why planets stay in orbit rather than falling into the Sun.
State the three IAU criteria that an object must meet to be classified as a major planet.
Distinguish between major planets, dwarf planets, and moons based on their orbital relationships.
Explain why Ceres and Pluto are classified as dwarf planets rather than major planets.
Teacher tips
These are the notes from teachers who have run the session.
Hook
Resist correcting anyone during the six images. The point is not to sort them, it is to get learners to notice they are already using a rule they cannot name. Ask: "What rule are you using to decide?"
The star is the one that exposes the most interesting confusion. Learners who call it a planet are reasoning from 'round bright object in space', which is exactly the reasoning the IAU rejected. Ask what the difference is between something that makes its own light and something that only reflects it.
The Moon will split the room, and that is the most useful disagreement of the session, so do not resolve it. Take both sides, write the arguments up, and leave it hanging. Come back to it after the pathways.
ITZA platform
Ask directly: what would happen to Earth if it stopped moving sideways tomorrow? The answer, that it would fall straight in, is what makes orbit make sense.
Circulate with one question ready: "if you discovered a new object tomorrow, how would you decide what to call it?" It primes the activity and it tells you immediately who has grasped that classification is a decision rather than a fact.
Classroom activity
Cover the Earth slide properly before moving on. Say all three rules out loud against the one object everybody already agrees about. Without that model, learners name the object instead of classifying it, and naming is not the skill you are after.
Insist that every verdict states which rule fails, not just yes or no. "Not a planet" is worth nothing. "Not a planet, because it orbits a planet rather than a star" is better. Where an object passes, encourage recitation of all three.
Rule 3 is where the errors will be. Learners read 'cleared its path' as 'nothing else is anywhere near it', which is not what it means and would disqualify most of the solar system. Say early that it means the object is the dominant thing in its lane, not that the lane is empty.
Plenary
Part 2 asks what changed. Expect "Pluto changed" or "the scientists were wrong". Both are worth hearing before you push. Pluto is exactly as it was in 1930. What changed is that we found thousands of similar objects and had to decide what that meant.
The lock-in quote is Alan Stern, who leads the New Horizons mission and is the most prominent scientific opponent of the definition this session teaches. He still argues Pluto is a planet. Saying so is a stronger ending than the quote alone, because it shows the argument is live.
Misconceptions to watch for
THEY'LL SAY
"The biggest objects are the planets."
ACTUALLY
Size is not one of the three rules. Saturn's moon Titan is larger than Pluto and larger than Mercury, and it is still a moon, because it orbits a planet rather than a star.
THEY'LL SAY
"The Moon formed at the same time as Earth."
ACTUALLY
It came later. A Mars-sized object called Theia struck the early Earth, and the debris thrown into orbit gradually gathered into the Moon.
THEY'LL SAY
"Why don't the planets fall into the Sun?"
ACTUALLY
They are falling. They are also moving sideways fast enough to keep missing. Take away the sideways motion and Earth would drop straight in.
THEY'LL ASK
"Pluto was always a dwarf planet."
ACTUALLY
It was the ninth planet from 1930 to 2006. Better telescopes then revealed thousands of similar bodies sharing its region, which is what forced the question.
Extension tasks
INVESTIGATE
The worst weather in the solar system
REFLECT
How do stars die?
NEXT
Session 3: The Solar System
Buit from GET SET Space
Our full 15-session programme into the science of the universe.
Pre-register for early access

Get the latest updates straight to your inbox